Indiana's Tax Tactics: Cigarette Taxes and the Shadow Economy
Indiana’s latest cigarette tax increase is more than just a strategy to bolster the state budget; it’s a nod to the historical bootlegging culture reminiscent of the Prohibition era. As state legislatives increase the per-pack price, new regulations impose stringent penalties aimed at curbing smuggling activities, evoking memories of mid-1900 raids on bootleggers.
The landscape has changed since the 1930s, when records detailed operations shutting down illicit alcohol and tobacco circuits. Now, the focus is on interstate routes and shopping centers where cost-conscious smokers cross state lines or hunt for bulk deals.
Neighboring Kentucky’s low cigarette tax, at just 10 cents per pack compared to Indiana’s current rate, makes it a prime source of contraband tobacco. Meanwhile, Tennessee experienced a rise in illegal cigarette operations near its borders following past tax hikes, drawing parallels to classic “speakeasies" but for cigarettes.
The broader narrative is complex. A 2018 report from Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School indicates that after Indiana’s 2007 hike from 55¢ to 99.5¢ per pack, tax revenue jumped 43% within a year, despite concerns about increased smuggling from nearby states.
This represents a modern twist on an old challenge, with Indiana targeting tobacco contraband as it once pursued moonshine.
New Enforcement Measures: What to Expect?
Starting July 1, Indiana will more than double the cigarette tax, introducing significant law enforcement measures:
Outlawing bulk out-of-state purchases, escalating these actions to felonious conduct.
Strengthened task forces, including Excise and state police, focusing on monitoring shipments at key points like toll booths and warehouses.
Random audits targeting wholesalers and retailers to intercept counterfeit tax stamps.
Projected revenue impact: $290 million annually, directed towards public health initiatives.
Border Challenges and Enforcement Gaps
Enforcement remains a critical challenge. Indiana’s proximity to low-tax states like Kentucky presents significant risks for illegal trade. A Tax Foundation report lists Indiana among the top ten states likely to see spikes in cigarette smuggling after tax hikes, warning of consumer evasion through cross-border shopping and gray-market sales.
Ohio, with its relatively low tax rate and extensive highway system, presents additional concerns. Research from the Mackinac Center predicts that up to 12% of cigarettes consumed in Indiana may result from out-of-state purchases post-hike.
Case Studies: Illinois and New York
Illinois:
Illinois recently increased nicotine taxes to 45% of wholesale, heightening smuggling dynamics.
About 30% of consumed cigarettes are estimated to be illicitly transported across borders.
Post-2019 tax hike, Illinois has enforced stringent penalties on unstamped packs ($20–$25 per pack) and targeted high-volume shipments to curb contraband activities.
New York:
Boasting one of the nation’s highest combined taxes, New York has experienced smuggling rates above 50%, peaking at 61% during its latest tax increase.
The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives alongside the state’s Tax Enforcement Office enforces major trafficking laws, targeting those handling 10,000+ cigarettes without necessary tax documentation.
The Legacy of Indiana’s Illicit Trade
Indiana’s entrenchment in bootlegging isn’t new. During the Prohibition era, the state was infamous for its active moonshine operations, especially in southern counties like Lawrence, Dubois, and Orange, with routes known as “Whiskey Roads.”
Today, the substance has changed—from alcohol to tobacco—but the methods hark back to older strategies: utilizing legal loopholes, taking advantage of geographical nuances, and moving products covertly.
Former Indiana Excise officer John Halverson captures this parallel: “Back then, it was stills in barns. Now it’s cartons in car trunks.”
Public Health Gain or Policy Gamble?
For some, the rise in smuggling may not denote policy failure. Health advocates argue that even with some price evasion, overall higher costs lead to significant smoking reductions, particularly among teens and low-income populations.
Mike Seilback, National Assistant Vice President for Advocacy at the American Lung Association, noted in The Indiana Capital Chronicle,
“Higher tobacco prices are the most effective deterrent to smoking, period. We foresee thousands of Hoosiers quitting, with thousands more youths never beginning.”
Even amid smuggling rates of 10–30%, studies indicate states may still realize significant net revenue post-tax hikes—as long as enforcement is rigorous. Indiana’s 2007 experience—a 41% drop in sales but a 43% revenue gain—demonstrates this potential.
Evaluating the Approach
Indiana’s gamble on increased revenues is substantial. Yet success depends on balancing deterrence with effective enforcement. Will local retailers adjust? And will new bootleggers, reminiscent of 1930s smugglers, adapt quickly enough?
Only time will reveal outcomes. However, the 1930s spirit is revived on the region's byways for now. With stakes elevated, vehicles sped up, and tax stamps intensified—but the chase? It endures as Indiana’s oldest tale.
Want tax & accounting tips and insights?
Sign up for our newsletter.
Contact
32158 Camino Capistrano A353
San Juan Capistrano, California 92675